Science
Acidity: the acids in wine and what each does
Tartaric, malic, lactic, citric and acetic acid — where they come from, how they differ, and why pH and total acidity are not the same measurement.
The short answer
Wine contains several different acids with different origins and different characters. Tartaric and malic acid come from the grape; lactic acid appears if malolactic fermentation takes place; acetic acid is produced by spoilage organisms and is a fault above low levels. Together they set how fresh a wine tastes, how stable it is, and how well it ages.
Overview
Acidity is what stops wine tasting flabby, and it is the single most important structural component in white wine — the equivalent of what tannin does for reds.
Unlike tannin, it is a taste rather than a texture: sourness is detected by taste receptors, and it also provokes salivation, which is why a high-acid wine makes the mouth water.
The acids are not interchangeable. Which ones are present, and in what proportion, changes the character as much as the total quantity does.
How it works
The mechanism, at the scope it has actually been established.
Tartaric acid is the principal acid in grapes and is unusual in being rare in other fruit. It is relatively stable through fermentation and is the main contributor to a wine’s pH. It can precipitate as potassium bitartrate crystals when the wine gets cold, which is what cold stabilisation is for.
Malic acid is the second major grape acid and is the same acid that makes a green apple sharp. It falls during ripening as the vine metabolises it, and it falls faster in warm conditions — which is a large part of why warm-region fruit arrives with lower acidity.
Lactic acid is not present in the grape. It appears when lactic acid bacteria convert malic acid during malolactic fermentation, and it is a weaker, softer-tasting acid. The conversion lowers total acidity and raises pH.
Acetic acid is the acid in vinegar and is produced by acetic acid bacteria and by some yeasts. Every wine contains a small amount; above roughly 0.6 to 0.9 g/L most tasters begin to notice it, and it is then treated as volatile acidity, a fault.
Citric acid is present in small quantities and may be added in some jurisdictions, within limits, though it is microbiologically less stable than the others.
Why it matters in the glass
Acidity is one of the most reliable predictors of how a wine will sit with food, because it cuts through fat and can mirror acidity in the dish.
It is also a preservative: low pH inhibits spoilage organisms, which is why high-acid wines are generally more microbiologically robust and often age longer.
And it is directly manipulable in the winery, which is why the same grape in the same place can produce noticeably different wines depending on whether malolactic fermentation was allowed to run.
Where you can see it
- Chablis
- Cool-site Chardonnay where producers commonly restrict or block malolactic fermentation to retain malic sharpness.
- German Riesling
- High tartaric and malic acid, which is what allows a wine with noticeable residual sugar to taste balanced rather than sweet.
- Warm-climate red
- Malic acid largely respired away during a long, hot ripening period; some jurisdictions permit acidification to compensate.
What people get wrong
1 widely repeated claim this page corrects.
Compounds named on this page
Where a compound comes from is chemistry; what it smells like is perception. These are kept apart deliberately.
- Tartaric acid
- The principal grape acid, unusual in being rare in other fruit.
- Malic acid
- The second grape acid — the one that makes a green apple sharp. Associated with green apple.
- Lactic acid
- Not present in grapes — produced by bacteria from malic acid during malolactic fermentation.
- Acetic acid
- The acid in vinegar. Present in every wine; a fault above low levels. Associated with vinegar, nail varnish. The AWRI reports that most tasters begin to notice volatile acidity somewhere around 0.6 to 0.9 g/L in table wine, with the exact point varying considerably by wine style — some fortified and oxidative styles carry far more without being considered faulty. Caution: Trace amounts are normal and can add complexity. There is no single figure above which a wine is faulty, because tolerance varies enormously by style.
Perceived sourness is only loosely predicted by any single measurement. Sugar, alcohol, tannin and carbon dioxide all modify it, which is why two wines with identical laboratory acidity can taste quite different.
Go shallower or deeper
The beginner page and the chemistry page are both correct, and neither substitutes for the other.
Sources
Sources consulted
- The Australian Wine Research Institute — AWRI
- International Code of Oenological Practices — OIV
- UC Davis Department of Viticulture and Enology — University of California, Davis
More in wine science
Science
Cool climate and warm climate
The single most useful distinction in wine — what it actually changes in the grape, and where the shorthand breaks down.
Science
Minerality: what the evidence actually shows
A word almost every taster uses, no agreed chemical definition, and no demonstrated route from vineyard rock to matching flavour.
Science
Oxygen: friend and enemy at every stage
Oxygen is needed in some quantities at some moments and damaging in others. What matters is how much, when, and to which wine.