Skip to content
WineHQ
Search

Winemaking

Corks, screwcaps and closures

How a bottle is sealed, and why it is a genuine trade-off rather than a quality signal.

Overview

Natural cork allows a small, variable amount of oxygen through over time, which many believe contributes positively to development. Its historic problem is TCA contamination, which has been substantially reduced but not eliminated.

Screwcaps eliminate cork taint entirely and allow very little oxygen through. That preserves freshness and can, in some wines, encourage reduction — which is a real trade-off, not a defect of the closure.

Technical closures — agglomerated cork, DIAM, synthetic — sit between the two and offer more consistent oxygen transmission than natural cork.

Australia and New Zealand adopted screwcaps close to universally as a deliberate industry decision. It was about eliminating TCA, not about cost.

Where the story and the evidence part company

The claim that screwcapped wine cannot age is not supported: long-term trials show screwcapped wine ageing well, though differently from cork-sealed wine.

Sources

Sources consulted

More in winemaking