Science
Yeast: the organisms doing the work
Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the non-Saccharomyces species that start most spontaneous ferments, and what strain choice does and does not determine.
The short answer
Saccharomyces cerevisiae completes almost all wine fermentations, because it tolerates alcohol levels that outcompete everything else. A spontaneous fermentation typically begins with a succession of other genera and finishes with Saccharomyces regardless of whether anybody added it.
Overview
Yeast are on grape skins, in vineyard soil, on equipment and throughout a winery building. A great deal of the resident population in an old cellar lives on the walls and the presses rather than arriving with the fruit.
The choice between inoculating with a cultured strain and letting the resident population work is one of the most argued-about decisions in winemaking, and one where the evidence is more equivocal than either side usually allows.
How it works
The mechanism, at the scope it has actually been established.
Grape must carries a diverse microbial population: Hanseniaspora, Candida, Metschnikowia, Pichia and others, alongside relatively small numbers of Saccharomyces.
In a spontaneous fermentation these non-Saccharomyces species dominate the first days, contributing their own metabolites, and are then progressively inhibited as ethanol rises. Most tolerate only a few percent alcohol.
Saccharomyces cerevisiae tolerates 15% and above and therefore finishes essentially every dry fermentation, which is why the succession converges even in wineries that never inoculate.
Cultured strains are selected for specific properties: reliable completion, alcohol tolerance, low hydrogen sulfide production, cold tolerance, foam behaviour, and in some cases the release of particular aroma compounds — the thiol-releasing strains used for Sauvignon Blanc being the best-known example.
Nitrogen is the limiting nutrient in most fermentations. Yeast assimilable nitrogen below roughly 150 mg/L is associated with sluggish fermentation and with hydrogen sulfide production, which is why nutrient additions are so routine.
Temperature bounds the whole process: too cold and fermentation stalls, too warm and yeast stress and die, typically above the mid-30s Celsius.
Why it matters in the glass
It is the mechanism behind stuck fermentation, behind reductive sulfur faults, and behind a great deal of the aromatic difference between two wines from the same fruit.
Compounds named on this page
Where a compound comes from is chemistry; what it smells like is perception. These are kept apart deliberately.
- Hydrogen sulfide
- Produced by stressed yeast; the rotten-egg end of reduction. Associated with rotten egg, drains. Caution: Often blows off with aeration. The heavier mercaptans it can react to form generally do not, which is why decanting sometimes helps and sometimes does not.
- Esters
- Fermentation-derived compounds responsible for much of the fruitiness in young wine. Associated with banana, pear drop, green apple, strawberry, tropical fruit. Caution: No single ester accounts for a descriptor. Attributing "banana" to isoamyl acetate is a shorthand, not an identification.
Whether spontaneous fermentation produces greater complexity is genuinely disputed. Trials find measurable compositional differences; whether tasters reliably prefer the result, and whether any difference reflects a site rather than a cellar’s resident population, is not established.
Sources
Sources consulted
- The Australian Wine Research Institute — AWRI
- UC Davis Department of Viticulture and Enology — University of California, Davis
- INRAE — French National Research Institute for Agriculture, Food and Environment — INRAE
More in wine science
Science
Acidity: the acids in wine and what each does
Tartaric, malic, lactic, citric and acetic acid — where they come from, how they differ, and why pH and total acidity are not the same measurement.
Science
Cool climate and warm climate
The single most useful distinction in wine — what it actually changes in the grape, and where the shorthand breaks down.
Science
Minerality: what the evidence actually shows
A word almost every taster uses, no agreed chemical definition, and no demonstrated route from vineyard rock to matching flavour.